No Tricks, Just Trusts: Avoiding Estate Planning Scares - Trusts & Estates and Elder Law & Special Needs Planning Newsletter
By: Monica Babula
An October reminder that the true estate planning frights usually come from outdated documents, unclear fiduciary duties, and missed deadlines.
As Halloween Approaches, Beware of the Estate Planning “Haunts” That Can Linger After Death
October is a fitting time to revisit the documents and decisions that can quietly haunt families long after a loved one has died. In both New Jersey and New York, many estate disputes do not arise because a person failed to plan at all, but rather because the planning was stale, incomplete, inconsistent with beneficiary designations, or unclear about who has authority to act and how fiduciaries must exercise that authority.
For clients, the lesson is simple: a will, trust, power of attorney or beneficiary designation should not be treated as a document to sign once and keep buried in a drawer. For fiduciaries, the lesson is equally important: serving as an executor, administrator, trustee, or agent under a power of attorney is not ceremonial. It carries legal duties that can expose the fiduciary to scrutiny, surcharge, removal, or litigation if mishandled.
Scare No. 1: The “Zombie” Estate Plan
A “zombie” estate plan is one that technically exists but no longer reflects the client’s life circumstances. Divorce, remarriage, the death or disability of a fiduciary, changed tax circumstances, changed wishes, the birth of grandchildren, relocation between states, or a breakdown in family relationships can all turn a once-sensible plan into a source of conflict.
New Jersey and New York each have their own rules governing probate, fiduciary authority, spousal rights, trust administration, and court procedure. A plan prepared in one state may still be valid after a move, but validity is only part of the analysis. The better question is whether the plan will work efficiently where the client now resides, owns property, and expects the estate or trust to be administered.
Scare No. 2: Spousal Rights That Rise from the Grave
Clients sometimes assume that a will or revocable trust can completely disinherit a spouse. That assumption can be dangerous. In New Jersey, a surviving spouse, civil union partner, or domestic partner may have a right to elect against the estate and claim one-third of the augmented estate, subject to statutory limitations and conditions. In New York, the surviving spouse’s elective share is generally the greater of $50,000 or one-third of the net estate.
These rules matter in planning and litigation. Lifetime transfers, beneficiary designations, jointly titled assets, prenuptial or postnuptial agreements, estrangement, separation, and prior marriages can all affect the analysis. The spooky part is timing: elective share rights are not theoretically forever. A surviving spouse who may have a claim must act promptly and in the proper court, or the right may be lost. In addition, the failure to consider the elective share right in your planning can cause disruption to your estate plan after your death.
Scare No. 3: Fiduciaries Who Do Not Know They Are Fiduciaries
One of the most common sources of estate and trust litigation is a fiduciary who treats the role informally. Executors, administrators, trustees, and agents under powers of attorney must keep assets separate, maintain records, communicate appropriately, avoid self-dealing, and act consistently with the governing instrument and applicable law. New Jersey law expressly recognizes that fiduciaries must administer trusts and estates in accordance with the governing document and, where applicable, act impartially based on what is fair and reasonable to beneficiaries. New York’s Estates, Powers and Trusts Law likewise contains detailed provisions governing fiduciary powers, duties, and limitations.
Fiduciaries should remember that silence can be as frightening as misconduct. Failure to account, failure to explain transactions, unexplained delays, commingling, or preferential treatment of one beneficiary over another can fuel suspicion and turn an otherwise routine administration into a contested proceeding.
Scare No. 4: Digital Assets and Paper Trails That Vanish
Modern estates often include online financial accounts, cryptocurrency, cloud storage, email, social media, loyalty points, electronic statements, and password-protected devices. If fiduciaries cannot identify, access, or value those assets, administration becomes more expensive and more contentious. Clients should maintain an updated inventory of assets, fiduciary contact information, and instructions for locating account records, while still safeguarding passwords and sensitive information.
Practical October Checklist:
- Review core documents. Confirm that wills, trusts, powers of attorney, health care directives, and beneficiary designations still reflect current wishes.
- Check fiduciary appointments. Make sure named executors, trustees, guardians, agents, and successors are willing, able, and appropriate.
- Coordinate probate and non-probate assets. Beneficiary designations, joint accounts, retirement accounts, and trust assets should be reviewed alongside the will.
- Consider spousal rights. In both New Jersey and New York, a surviving spouse may have statutory rights that cannot simply be ignored.
- Document fiduciary decisions. Fiduciaries should keep records, explain material decisions, and avoid informal shortcuts.
- Inventory digital assets. Make it possible for the right person to identify and administer digital property when the time comes.
The Bottom Line
Estate planning should bring peace of mind, not suspense. A thoughtful October review can help ensure that documents are current, fiduciaries understand their duties, and families are not left to confront avoidable disputes after a death or incapacity. In Trusts and Estates practice, the scariest problems are often the ones that could have been prevented with timely planning, clear drafting, and careful administration. The Trusts and Estates attorneys at Pashman Stein Walder Hayden P.C. can help you with that.
Learn more about our Trust & Estates and Elder Law & Special Needs Planning Practices.
* * *
The information contained herein is for informational purposes only and not for the purpose of providing legal advice. You should contact your attorney to obtain advice with respect to any particular issue or problem. Use of and access to these materials do not create an attorney-client relationship between Pashman Stein Walder Hayden P.C. and/or its attorneys, and the reader of the materials.
